1. Home
  2. Commission Votes: September 2026

Commission Votes: September 2026

Please note that some items posted here are edited to ensure compliance with the EEOC's statutory confidentiality requirements. Items that have been updated since they were originally posted are highlighted and will remain highlighted until the next month’s posting. 

Date of Final Vote Document Type Matter Statute, Issues, and Bases InvolvedCommissioner Vote Result Document Link 
9/2/2026Litigation Recommendation – Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Continental Inn III, et al.Title VII

Sex

Retaliation

Harassment

Demotion

Discharge

Individual
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Continental Inn III, et al.
9/8/2026Litigation Recommendation – Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionLitigation RecommendationPWFA

Title VII 

Pregnancy

Sex

Failure to Hire

Individual
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0) 
9/8/2026Litigation Recommendation – Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Solera Holdings, LLCADA 

Disability 

Retaliation

Terms/
Conditions 

Discharge 

Reasonable Accommodation
 
Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve
 
Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Solera Holdings, LLC
9/8/2026Federal Sector Appellate DecisionNia G. v. EEOC, EEOC Appeal No. 2025004389Title VII

National Origin

Color

Sex

Race

Retaliation 
Lucas: Recuse

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (2-0)Nia G. v. EEOC, EEOC Appeal No. 2025004389
9/8/2026Federal Sector Appellate DecisionDinah L. v. EEOC, EEOC Appeal No. 2024002904Rehabilitation Act

Disability 

Retaliation  
Lucas: Recuse 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
Approved (2-0)Dinah L. v. EEOC, EEOC Appeal No. 2024002904
9/8/2026Federal Sector Appellate DecisionNicole M. v. EEOC, EEOC Appeal No. 2022003454Title VII 

Sex

Race

Retaliation 

Promotion
Lucas: Recuse

Kotagal: Approve
 
Panuccio: Approve 
Approved (2-0)Nicole M. v. EEOC, EEOC Appeal No. 2022003454
9/9/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Wagner Equipment, Co.ADA 

Disability

Retaliation

Qualification Standard

Reasonable Accommodation

Discharge

Individual
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve
 
Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Wagner Equipment, Co.
9/10/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Ollie’s Bargain Outlet, Inc.ADA

Disability

Hiring

Qualification Standard

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Recuse 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (2-0)EEOC v. Ollie’s Bargain Outlet, Inc.
9/10/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionLitigation RecommendationADA

Retaliation

Disability

Qualification Standard

Reasonable Accommmodation

Discharge

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve
 
Panuccio: Approve 
Approved (3-0) 
9/10/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Eastern Shipbuilding Group, Inc.ADA

Record of Disability

Disability

Hiring 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Eastern Shipbuilding Group, Inc.
9/15/2026Recommendation to Participate as Amicus CuriaeDarst v. Meigs CountyADEA

Age
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
Approved (3-0)Darst v. Meigs County
9/15/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 2 of ResolutionEEOC v. Circa Hospitality Group III, LLC d/b/a Circa Resort and CasinoTitle VII 

Religion 

Retaliation 

Terms/ Conditions 

Discharge 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Circa Hospitality Group III, LLC d/b/a Circa Resort and Casino
9/15/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Davis Cartage Co.Title VII 

Sex 

Sexual Harassment 

Class 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Davis Cartage Co.
9/15/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionU.S. EEOC v. Trancasa USA, Inc.ADEA 

Age 

Terms/ Conditions 

Hiring 

Class 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)U.S. EEOC v. Trancasa USA, Inc.
9/16/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. BNSF Railway Co.ADA 

Disability 

Retaliation 

Hiring 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Discharge 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. BNSF Railway Co.
9/16/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Sibitalent Corp.Title VII 

National Origin 

Referral 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Sibitalent Corp.
9/17/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Southwest LTC - Lawton LLC et al.ADA 

Disability 

Retaliation 

Harassment 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Discharge 

Interference 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Southwest LTC - Lawton LLC et al.
9/17/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Majestic Developers, LLCADA 

Disability 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Discharge 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Majestic Developers, LLC
9/18/2026Recommendation to Participate as Amicus CuriaeBell v. Lhoist North America of Texas, LLCTitle VII 

Retaliation 
 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
Approved (3-0)Bell v. Lhoist North America of Texas, LLC
9/18/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Summit Hospitality Group, Ltd., d/b/a Residence Inn Raleigh DowntownADA 

Disability 

Discharge 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Summit Hospitality Group, Ltd., d/b/a Residence Inn Raleigh Downtown
9/18/2026Subpoena DeterminationDetermination on the Petition to Modify or Revoke Subpoena Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0) 
9/21/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. GSK Research, Inc. et al.ADA 

Disability 

Retaliation 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Discharge 

Terms/Conditions
 
Class 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve
 
Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. GSK Research, Inc. et al.
9/23/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Learjet, Inc. d/b/a BombardierADA 

Disability 

Reasonable Accommodation
 
Hiring 

Qualification Standard 

Class 
Lucas: Disapprove 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (2-1)EEOC v. Learjet, Inc. d/b/a Bombardier
9/23/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Bollinger Shipyards, LLC, et al.ADA 

Disability 

Hiring 

Qualification Standard 

Class 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Bollinger Shipyards, LLC, et al.
9/24/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 2 of ResolutionU.S. EEOC v. Sequoias Tree Expert, LLCTitle VII 

Sex 

Hiring 

Class 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
Approved (3-0)U.S. EEOC v. Sequoias Tree Expert, LLC
9/24/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Call 4 Health, Inc.PWFA 

Pregnancy 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Constructive Discharge 

Discharge 

Class 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Call 4 Health, Inc.
9/28/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 2 of ResolutionLitigation RecommendationTitle VII 

Religion 

Discipline 

Discharge 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Disapprove
 
Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (2-1) 
9/28/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. United Parcel Service, Inc.ADA 

Disability 

Hiring 

Reasonable Accommodation
 
Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. United Parcel Service, Inc.
9/28/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. St. Louis Arc, Inc.Title VII 

PWFA 

Sex 

Pregnancy 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Discharge 

Leave 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. St. Louis Arc, Inc.
9/28/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionLitigation RecommendationTitle VII 

Sex 

National Origin 

Race 

Retaliation 

Discharge 

Sexual Harassment 

Harassment 

Constructive Discharge 

Transfer 

Class 
Lucas: Disapprove 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Disapprove 
 
Disapproved (1-2) 
9/29/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraph 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Optima Care Secaucus, LLC d/b/a Optima Care FountainsADA 

Disability 

Reasonable Accommodation
 
Discharge 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve 

Kotagal: Approve 

Panuccio: Approve 
 
Approved (3-0)EEOC v. Optima Care Secaucus, LLC d/b/a Optima Care Fountains
9/29/2026Litigation Recommendation - Case Presented to Commission Pursuant to Paragraphs 1 and 3 of ResolutionEEOC v. Wal-Mart Stores East, LPADA 

Disability 

Reasonable Accommodation 

Terms/ Conditions 

Individual 
Lucas: Approve - Reasonable Accommodation; Disapprove - Terms/Conditions

Panuccio: Recuse

Kotagal: Approve
Reasonable Accommodation:
Approved 
(2-0) 

Terms/Conditions:
Disapproved
(1-1) 
EEOC v. Wal-Mart Stores East, LP
Enabled In-page Navigation